[Pga_europe_process] we must lynch javier, he is a violent
racist and a traitor that works on the ESF
dianhuburlon at gmx.net
Wed Jun 23 13:59:18 CEST 2004
I am very surprise see that you take the time to answer such continuous
and agresive emails, coming clearly from a very macho mind and values.
The so called activists from West Essex, regarding our call for solidarity,
sent to the social movement of Asia the following beauty (among others) ,
more expected from the Catolic Church or the World Bank than from an activist.
"We do not appreciate this lack of solidarity which simply thrusts a
begging bowl in our face and then spits in our face because we do not have
This kind of agresive insults and emails, ---- coming from who I suppose is
a big white male patriarca, with access to toilet, fridge and specially
ascess to education and to a lot of books, and after reading such books,
beliving he is above everyone, with the superior morality of the pure
anarchism or anti authoritarian, and then speaking to the rest of humanity
from the pulpit of the cathedral, dreaming being the Pope of the
anarchisch, or maybe as Attack, thinking "they are the real
movement".-- are not worth to be answered.
Many Asian organizations thought in giving the deserved answer to such
shit, but at the end, we really have better things to do.
I saw them insisting in the provocation, but really, it is useless to
disscuss with such agresive macho close minds, morally above the rest
of human beings. All time agresive, all time insulting, ..and of course,
this kind of authoritarian, impositive and agresive way of communication in
the name of anti-authoritarian, anaschism, direct democracy, anti sexist
and so on. Typical reproduction of the typical power of patriarchy and
authoritarism in the anti authoritarians movements. Nothing new. Really,
not worth to bother about. They are not open for discussion, only for
"argument", and if possible to humiliate the person in front. So, what is
the use? Take easy and don´t bother about.
I promised Vanja to come back Europe in a couple of weeks. ( I am stucked
in Delhi). Are you going to be around? I really would like to disscuss with
you regarding the social forum. What on the hell are you doing there? I
really don´t understand why lost energy and time in it. More. I don´t
understand why to be there to legitimaze it. I read a couple of emails on
the issue months ago, but I didn´t want to enter into the discussion. But I
was very surprise that someone wrote that we will be isolated as movements
if we don´t participate. If that is the case, I really want to be
isolated. It is clear that the biggest strengh of PGA Asia is the good
analisis they have of those spaces and the radical position of the
movements, and don´t let themselves to be eaten by such spaces, as it is
happening in LA. I don´t think it is a question of spending hours
critizazing the WSF, who funds it and so on, but...whatever, I would really
like to hear your opinion regarding this issue.
At 15:27 22/06/2004 +0100, javier wrote:
>Dear WE Zapatistas
>I can only assume you were writing about me. I am sorry about the delay
>in my reply, I was in the ESF preparation meeting in Berlin, very hard
>Lets clarify a few things. I didnÂ´t write the lines below. I quote
>replied to another message.
>It is true that we had a discussion on the word ghetto in Belgrade,
>where people explained the different arguments for and against its use
>in this context. That's why in my letter to Nina I actually wrote
>"breaking self-imposed ghettos" a formulation I find appropriate, and
>you can call me whatever.
>I am getting used to people using identity politics as a way to end
>discussions. It happens all the time in the UK social forum, where the
>diverse SWP front groups morally blackmail us on these lines: "If you
>are against my politics you are against all the million
>refugees/women/migrants, etc..." corollary: you are a racist/sexist,
>etc. We were even accused of being against Nelson Mandela for demanding
>a proper democratic process for choosing guest star speakers!!
>What I find quite sad is to see the same thing happening in the PGA
>This takes me to the next point: my forthcoming holiday in Belgrade. I
>was hoping the ESF would put me a proper bureaucrat dacha by the Black
>Sea, but things are not as good as in the old days... so I will have to
>settle by sharing a dusty field with lots of lousy dreadlocked
>anarchohippies. I just hope there are no cameras! Rather dead than seen
>having gone so low in life.
>I admit this is my motivation, but not what I told my Essex Zapatista
>friends, they could only be guessing. What I told them was that I was
>spending a lot of energy working behind the lines in enemy field, ie the
>ESF process, to carve out space for the type of non-authoritarian
>politics we share around PGA of decentralisation, autonomy, diversity,
>etc. And that I really didn't have the energy to engage with their
>arguments, or more precisely with their style of arguing.
>What could have been understood as a holiday is that I said that for me
>the ESF was the place to fight with all the SWP, etc, and the PGA the
>place were we could have a different dynamic, less emotionally draining.
>You can read this as the difference between politics and holiday, or as
>someone who hopes one day politics will be modelled on something other
>than war and conflict, and we could be that beginning.
>On Thu, 2004-06-17 at 07:16, paki.tv at cyber-rights.net wrote:
> > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> > Hash: SHA1
> > On Tue, 15 Jun 2004 06:37:59 -0700 javier <javier at spc.org> wrote:
> > >Global movement : Are we a mouvement ? what next ? Going out of the
> > >ghetto ? : skrati[AT]yahoo.com / javier[AT]spc.org
> > >>
> > We have had a discussion about the use of the word Ghetto and its use
> > in this way has been shown to be racist.
> > What does that mean?
> > It means that when discussions are put out with this heading, is thta
> > most Black people will be less inclined to attend the conference because
> > they know the organisers are taking the piss.
> > As this is an issue which has already been raised, I can only assume
> > that the use of it here is deliberate, a sort of "hardboy" machismo about
> > not caring for sissy quibbles.
> > After the postponement of PGA meeting the author spoke to us dissmissively
> > suggesting that the issues we were raising were trvial.
> > This is how institutional racism works in the PGA.
> > The final insult was to be told that they considered their work in the
> > European Social Forum as their real political work, and PGA as a holiday
> > . . . this from a person who the PGA paid to go to a preparatory meeting
> > in Belgrade.
> > How can these issues be left to the conference when it is precisely now,
> > just as Nico himself pointed out, the white middle class guys are going
> > around dominating.
> > Seems like these alternatives to capitalism are simply the same old "shit"
> > (to use one of Nico's favourite terms) in new bottles.
> > That's all for now, folks!
> > West Essex Zapatista
> > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
> > Note: This signature can be verified at https://www.hushtools.com/verify
> > Version: Hush 2.4
> > wkYEARECAAYFAkDRNx0ACgkQyf+VSI0vK4YqXwCgmX1X6IpHZJ+Svj7XtMz08LRe60gA
> > oL3Q2aDTxCXHljdbys6kRtAKjrYu
> > =7D57
> > -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
> > Get your free encrypted email at http://www.cyber-rights.net
>Pga_europe_process mailing list
>Pga_europe_process at squat.net
More information about the Pga_europe_process